despair

Damn! All my training is for shit! Here is a clever sign, but I can't explain why. Is this an example of irony? And if it's irony, is it dramatic irony? Or situational? Maybe verbal? Oh, the shame of being a member of Las Departamento de English and not being able to identify a smart rhetorical play when I see it! The shame!



Comments

B said…
hmm....it seems they're just playing off the one man/one woman verses & suggesting, you uphold that, but yet you don't uphold this verse? what kind of irony would that be? situational maybe...
September 22, 2009 at 10:30 AM
Kaijsa said…
I saw that on the Stranger. I'd say it's more of an "Oh, snap!" kind of thing. It's calling them out on hypocrisy, but is a form of irony, I think. Like, it's ironic that the very text you're using to argue against gay marriage also condemns the majority of straight marriage.
September 22, 2009 at 1:14 PM
Rick said…
Irony, says Merriam-Webster, is "incongruity between the actual result of a sequence of events and the normal or expected result." So I think maybe Beth is right--the expected sequence of events is that Xans would weigh both sets of verses (anti-gay; anti-premarital-sex) equally, but instead there's a situational incongruity, in which one set of verses is nearly overlooked while the other is still used as justification for Phelpsish judgement and bigotry. Maybe? Do I get any bonus points for for using "Phelpsish" in my response?
September 22, 2009 at 11:52 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

options

Image
It's sort of exciting (and relatively rare) for me to find three different frames that I like. Now the hard part is narrowing it down to one. After having asked a couple of the staff at the eye doctor's, my roommate, and Stephanie, an early leader is emerging. But I'm open to other feedback..... Option 1 Option 2 Option 3 Comments?
Read more

citizens arrest

What are the rules for citizens arrest? Specifically, if there's a girl talking on her cell phone, with half her car windows frosted over, who doesn't wait her turn at the four-way, would I get in trouble if I pulled her out of her car and slapped her with her phone a couple of times? I suppose that doesn't quite count as citizens arrest. Vigilante justice, maybe. Whack, whack! In less aggravating news, tomorrow is the last day of classes for the semester. Finally. It's been a long time comin' this fall. I really should start thinking about the trip to WV and AZ and start planning some Christmas gifty-gifts.
Read more